Itoje Dismisses England Squad Rift Claims After Italy Argument
Rugby Union3 min read

Itoje Dismisses England Squad Rift Claims After Italy Argument

12 Mar 202612 Mar 2026 espn.com

England captain Maro Itoje has denied any lasting tensions in the squad following his heated exchange with fly-half Fin Smith during their defeat to Italy. The captain insisted the on-field disagreement was quickly resolved and reflected healthy team dynamics ahead of their crucial clash with France in Paris.

Key Takeaways

  • 1.As always, the way I try to do things is I like to hear what my key decision makers think of what is going on, and whoever plays 10 they will obviously have an important role in that," he explained.
  • 2."You don't often see me with a mic, I'm not always mic'd up but maybe I'm portraying a false image!" Itoje provided insight into his leadership approach, emphasizing the importance of consulting key decision-makers during matches.
  • 3."I actually think it's a good thing that people in the team feel they can express a view and in sport, if anything, that's the most kosher of fallouts that the world has ever seen.

England captain Maro Itoje has firmly dismissed suggestions of division within the squad following his heated on-field exchange with fly-half Fin Smith during their disappointing 23-18 defeat to Italy in the Six Nations.

The disagreement occurred early in the second half when England's leadership group debated whether to kick for goal or attempt an attacking lineout from a penalty. The debate escalated when Itoje was heard shouting at Smith: "Don't argue with me! Take the three."

With England facing a crucial fixture against France in Paris on Saturday, Itoje moved quickly to quash any speculation about squad harmony. "There's no crack. There's no crack between us. Fin's a good guy and I get on with him very well," Itoje said.

Tyler Smith — NBA Forward for Dallas Mavericks
Tyler Smith — NBA Forward for Dallas Mavericks

Team Dynamics

Team Dynamics

The Saracens lock explained that strong relationships within the team actually facilitate such discussions. "When you have good relationships with people you're able to have those sorts of conversations and are able to move on from it pretty quickly," he added.

"When you have good relationships with people you're able to have those sorts of conversations and are able to move on from it pretty quickly,"

Tolu Smith — NBA Forward for Detroit Pistons
Tolu Smith — NBA Forward for Detroit Pistons

The incident marked the first time the British and Irish Lions captain has been heard raising his voice so forcefully on the field. However, Itoje played down the exchange with characteristic humour.

"I didn't really lose it!" the lock laughed. "You don't often see me with a mic, I'm not always mic'd up but maybe I'm portraying a false image!"

Itoje provided insight into his leadership approach, emphasizing the importance of consulting key decision-makers during matches. "Fin is my guy. As always, the way I try to do things is I like to hear what my key decision makers think of what is going on, and whoever plays 10 they will obviously have an important role in that," he explained.

The captain described the sequence of events leading to the heated exchange. "I initially asked what we thought we should do and I guess he expressed a view, I expressed a view, and I just wanted to quickly move on to the next thing," Itoje said.

"I initially asked what we thought we should do and I guess he expressed a view, I expressed a view, and I just wanted to quickly move on to the next thing,"

Rather than viewing the incident negatively, Itoje suggested it demonstrated healthy team dynamics. "I actually think it's a good thing that people in the team feel they can express a view and in sport, if anything, that's the most kosher of fallouts that the world has ever seen. We have had far more blunt conversations between ourselves and other teammates!" he said.

England's squad has spent three days at a training camp in Verona before arriving in Paris on Thursday. Head coach Steve Borthwick has made one personnel change for the Stade de France encounter, selecting Ollie Chessum at blindside flanker with Sam Underhill dropping to the bench.

Looking Ahead

Looking Ahead

Looking Ahead

The match against France represents a crucial opportunity for England to end their three-game losing streak and salvage something from a disappointing championship campaign. Borthwick received a vote of confidence from the Rugby Football Union following the Italy defeat, with the summer tour now seen as vital in determining his future as England head coach ahead of the 2027 World Cup.

More Stories